Executive compensation benchmarking and CEO salary benchmarking for private companies

Executive compensation benchmarking compares what you pay your CEO, CFO and vice presidents with what similar companies pay for the same scope. For a private company under 200 people, the honest anchor is public federal wage data positioned for your size: the May 2025 BLS median for chief executives is $213,990, but that figure covers companies of every size, so a smaller firm usually sets base pay between the 25th percentile and the median. WageList does that pricing, aging and range setting for you, with the source on record.

Price an executive role in the builder on the right. Below are the actual BLS percentiles for three executive roles, a worked example for a 120 person company, and a plain comparison with consultants and executive surveys.

Built for founders, owners and boards setting leadership pay

Pay band builder U.S. BLS OES, May 2025
Market
Seniority
Company stage
The problem

Why executive pay is the hardest number to defend at a small company

At a company of 40 or 150 people, executive pay is usually set once, by the founder or the first investor, and then left alone. Three things go wrong from there. The CEO's pay drifts away from the market in one direction or the other. A new CFO or VP is hired from a larger company and their offer resets the scale for everyone else. And when an investor, a lender, the IRS or a new board member asks how the number was set, nobody can show the work.

Most of what you find when you search for executive compensation benchmarking is written for public company boards. Those boards build peer groups from proxy statements, which the SEC executive compensation disclosure rules require public companies to file. A private company with 120 employees has no peers in that set. Its realistic sources are a paid executive survey, a consultant, or public wage data adjusted for size.

The question also has tax and governance angles. An S corporation owner who works in the business has to take a reasonable salary, which our S corp reasonable salary page explains, and a nonprofit board has to document that executive pay is not excessive, covered on the nonprofit executive compensation page. In both cases a sourced market figure is the first thing anyone will ask to see.

Market data

What federal wage data says about executive base pay

The BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program publishes annual wage percentiles for every occupation, chief executives included. These are the national May 2025 figures for the three occupations a small company's leadership team most often maps to.

BLS May 2025 national annual wage percentiles for three executive occupations
Occupation (SOC) Typical title 25th percentile Median 75th percentile
Chief executives (11-1011)CEO, president, executive director$129,540$213,990$356,200
Financial managers (11-3031)CFO, VP finance, controller$125,490$166,570$219,980
General and operations managers (11-1021)COO, VP operations, general manager$72,320$105,770$167,280

Two things in this table matter more than the medians. The spread is huge: a chief executive at the 75th percentile earns 2.75 times one at the 25th. That is company size showing through, because the occupation counts the head of a ten person firm and the head of a large regional employer in the same row. And the financial manager row is tighter, because the job is more alike across sizes. So the choice of percentile is the real decision in executive benchmarking, more than the choice of source.

The figures are base wages. They leave out bonus, equity and benefits, which is right for setting a base pay range and wrong if you try to compare them with a total compensation number from a proxy statement.

Worked example

Pricing three executive roles for a 120 person company

A privately held services company with 120 employees and a single location is reviewing leadership pay for a January 2027 effective date. The source is the BLS table above. The positioning choices are ours, written down so the board can disagree with them line by line.

Three executive roles priced from BLS data with positioning, aging and range
Role Positioned figure Aged x 1.059 Midpoint Range
CEO$171,765$181,901$182,000$145,600 to $218,400
CFO$146,030$154,647$154,500$123,600 to $185,400
VP of operations$136,525$144,582$144,500$115,600 to $173,400

Now compare with what the company pays. Say the CEO, a founder, takes $150,000, the CFO hired last year from a larger firm earns $190,000, and the VP of operations, promoted from inside, earns $118,000. Against the midpoints the compa-ratios are 0.82, 1.23 and 0.82. The CFO sits above the top of the range, which is common when a hire comes from a bigger company and is a reason to hold that salary flat at the next review rather than to cut it. The VP is barely inside the range for a job that runs most of the business, which is the retention risk worth fixing first. The founder's figure is a choice, but if the company is an S corporation it is also the number the IRS will look at.

The compa-ratio calculator runs the same check for the rest of the team, and the salary structure page shows how these three ranges sit on top of the grades below them, so a senior manager's range does not overlap the VP's.

Comparison

Consultants, executive surveys and WageList compared

Each route wins somewhere. The right one depends on how much of the package you need to cover and who will read the result.

Executive compensation benchmarking routes compared on scope, cost and fit
Route Covers Cost Turnaround Best for
Compensation consultantBase, bonus, equity, custom peer group, board memoProject quote, often five figuresWeeksVenture backed boards, pre IPO companies, contested CEO pay
Executive salary surveyBase and incentives cut by revenue or headcountPer edition, cheaper if you submit dataDays once boughtHR teams pricing many executive roles each year
WageListBase pay from public BLS data, positioned, aged and ranged$99 a month or $588 a yearMinutesOwners and founders of 10 to 200 person companies who need a sourced base range

Where a consultant is the better buy: a venture backed company setting a CEO equity grant, a company preparing for a sale where pay will be diligenced, or a board split on the CEO's pay. Federal data does not cover equity, and a contested decision deserves an independent adviser. Our list of compensation consulting firms covers who does that work, and the salary survey providers comparison lists who sells executive survey cuts. For everyone else, base pay is the part that needs a defensible number every year, and that is the part WageList prices.

Checklist

What the board file should contain

Whichever route you take, the record that makes executive pay defensible is short. Keep one page per role with:

That page answers a new investor, a lender, an auditor and a successor board member alike. WageList keeps the source, date and method with every band it produces, so the file is mostly written for you. If the same review also has to cover the rest of the company, job pricing software explains how the non executive roles are priced the same way.

FAQ

Executive compensation benchmarking questions answered

How do you benchmark executive compensation?

Match each executive role to a market job by scope, not by title, then pull pay data for companies like yours in size, industry and location. Age the data to the date the pay applies, pick a target percentile, and set a range around it. Record the peer group, sources and date so the board can see how the number was built.

What percentile should executive pay be set at?

Most companies target the median of a well chosen peer group, and move above it only for a stated reason such as a hard to fill role or a turnaround mandate. When the only data available covers all company sizes, a private company under 200 employees usually lands between the 25th percentile and the median for base pay.

Where can a private company get executive compensation data?

Public companies disclose executive pay in proxy statements, which are useful for very large peers only. Private companies use paid executive surveys, consultant studies, or public federal wage data such as the BLS figures for chief executives and financial managers, adjusted for company size. Nonprofits can also compare Form 990 filings.

How much does executive compensation benchmarking cost?

A compensation consultant engagement for an executive team is usually quoted per project and often runs into five figures. Executive survey reports are sold per edition. WageList prints its price, $99 a month or $588 a year, and prices executive base pay from public federal data for companies of 10 to 200.

How often should executive compensation be benchmarked?

Once a year, ahead of the board or owner review, and again whenever the role changes materially, the company crosses a funding or revenue step, or you hire an executive from outside. Annual checks keep base pay from drifting, which is the main risk at a small company where the founder sets pay once and forgets it.

Does executive compensation benchmarking include bonus and equity?

A full study covers base, annual bonus, long term incentives and benefits. Base pay is the part every company needs and the part public data covers well. Bonus and equity depend heavily on ownership structure and stage, so small companies usually set base from market data and design the incentive on top as a percentage of base.

WageList

Set leadership pay you can explain to the board

WageList prices your executive and staff roles from the same public data, ages it to your effective date and keeps the method on file. See pricing and create your account to price your leadership team today.

Get started